21-02-2017, 08:56 AM
I also agree that Gridsquare-based scoring is the best option. In my view, it rewards participation over size of setup. So, the single op in his car on a hilltop with his 6/2/70 capable radio and small antennas can log an impressive score provided that he/she works at it.
I agree with Peter about the multipliers, except that maybe the higher microwave bands deserve a higher multiplier. Again, it's about reward for effort - the higher bands are both more difficult to build equipment for and more difficult to work any distance to another gridsquare. We also should be encouraging activity up higher as these bands become more under threat.
I'd change the Sub-Sections to VHF (6/2/70), Microwave (23 and up) and Open, treating Digital contacts the same as any other mode While you might work a more distant square, each Digital contact usually takes much more time and effort. We should be encouraging the use of modern comms modes, not shoving them to the side.
Fully utilising the 8-hour period is also an issue. If you do Saturday afternoon, then you are most likely pulling antennas down in the dark (after 8pm). 8 hours on Sunday morning is not viable for many reasons. I would suggest that 6 hours is more practical.
Regards,
Dave
VK3HZ
I agree with Peter about the multipliers, except that maybe the higher microwave bands deserve a higher multiplier. Again, it's about reward for effort - the higher bands are both more difficult to build equipment for and more difficult to work any distance to another gridsquare. We also should be encouraging activity up higher as these bands become more under threat.
I'd change the Sub-Sections to VHF (6/2/70), Microwave (23 and up) and Open, treating Digital contacts the same as any other mode While you might work a more distant square, each Digital contact usually takes much more time and effort. We should be encouraging the use of modern comms modes, not shoving them to the side.
Fully utilising the 8-hour period is also an issue. If you do Saturday afternoon, then you are most likely pulling antennas down in the dark (after 8pm). 8 hours on Sunday morning is not viable for many reasons. I would suggest that 6 hours is more practical.
Regards,
Dave
VK3HZ